Paige Conley Murder: A Dark Tale Of Betrayal

Paige Conley Murder

Paige Conley murder case made headlines in 2015 when she was charged with the murder of her mother, Carlene Conley. 

The horrifying death of Carlene at her daughter’s hands cast a long and dark shadow over the entire community. 

Despite Paige’s hardships during her upbringing, the brutal act she committed against her mother remains indefensible. 

The events that ultimately led to Paige’s conviction and imprisonment, stunned the public. 

Beyond the details of the crime, Paige’s profound mental health struggles have continued to captivate public attention, promising to remain a subject of discussion and debate for years to come.

Let’s look into the background context of Paige’s life, the events that led to her committing murder, her trial, and where she stands today.

Who is Paige Conley?

Paige Conley was a 39-year-old woman who lived with her mother, Carlene, in Independence, Kentucky. 

She had a tumultuous childhood, with her parents separating as a teenager. 

This separation took a toll on Paige, and she indulged in drugs and alcohol at a very young age to escape reality. 

Her life was further complicated by her experimentation with sex and her tendency to get into fights.

Despite her challenges, Paige remained with her mother even as she became an adult. 

Her mother was aware of her issues and tried to be there as much as possible. However, Paige’s impulsive behaviour and short temper frequently got her into trouble.

The events that led to the murder

On March 24, 2015, Paige and her mother disagreed when things spiraled out of control. 

Paige’s temper got the best of her, and she pushed her mother to the ground. She then grabbed a knife and stabbed her mother multiple times until she died.

When the police arrived, Paige called 911 and reported that her mother had been killed by trick-or-treaters who had entered their home. 

However, this theory was quickly discredited as there were no trick-or-treaters in March, and Paige was covered in her mother’s blood. 

The police also found over 70 stab wounds on the victim’s body, suggesting that the murder was an act of intense hatred.

Investigating the scene, the police found no signs of forced entry, indicating that the crime was committed by someone who had access to the house. 

Consequently, the police arrested Paige and charged her with her mother’s murder.

Paige’s trial and conviction

Paige Conley murder trial for her mother’s murder began in 2017 and was characterized by contradictions in her statements about what had happened. 

She first claimed that drug dealers had been targeting her, then changed her story several times, claiming that her mother had attacked her first before she retaliated. 

Paige also alleged that she had been hit on the head with an object, which caused her to forget the events that had transpired.

Paige’s defense team tried to argue that her previous mental health issues and her mother’s alleged abuse had pushed her to commit the murder. 

However, the jury was unconvinced and found her guilty. 

Additionally, Paige’s family members claimed she had been abusive towards her mother before, forcing the latter to seek medical attention. 

The jury sentenced Paige to 27 years in prison in 2017.

Paige’s appeal and subsequent plea deal

Paige appealed her conviction in 2019, claiming she had not been allowed a complete mental health examination despite mentioning her mental health issues.

The court granted her a new trial, but Paige decided against the recent problem and opted for a plea deal. 

This plea deal saw her receive a sentence of 20 years in prison.

Where is Paige Conley now?

Paige is incarcerated at the Kentucky Correctional Institution for Women and will be eligible for parole in 2032. 

She has been diagnosed with bipolar disorder and undergoing treatment for several years. 

Her family members have since come forward to try and make peace with the events that unfolded, stating that they want to put the past behind them and move on.